Scientific Research Review Assignment 4: Advancements and Ethical Practices in Your Study Area Literature Synthesis
| University | Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) |
| Subject | Research Methodology |
Assignment 4: Review Paper
Weightage: 15%
Course Outcome (CO): Identify appropriate research methods for a research project and
scientific writing ethics (A4, EM)
Program Outcome (PO4): Merancang dan melaksanakan tugas penyelidikan secara
profesional, beretika dan bertanggungjawab
Assignment Instructions
You are required to write an individual review paper on a topic on advancements in your
area of study. This paper must demonstrate your ability to plan, execute, and present a
scholarly task ethically and professionally. You are encouraged to reuse, expand, or
refine materials (e.g., literature, annotated sources, tables, or review structure)
developed in your previous assignments.
Your review must:
- Synthesise a minimum of 10 academic sources (Scopus/WoS indexed journals).
- Include critical reflection and not just summary.
- Show ethical writing practices in tone, structure, and referencing.
Format:
- Word count: 1,500–2,000 words
- APA referencing style
- Submission: PDF format via PutraBlast
- Deadline: 3 weeks from the assignment date
Suggested Structure of Review Paper
- Title
- Abstract (150–200 words)
- Introduction
- Background and significance of the topic
- Purpose and scope of the review
- Thematic Review (2–4 structured themes)
- Theme 1: Analysis with supporting sources
- Theme 2: Analysis with comparisons
- Theme 3 (optional): Emerging issues or innovations
- Discussion
- Implications for research practice or ethics
- Identify trends, gaps, or limitations in the reviewed works
- Conclusion
- Key insights and recommendations
- References (APA style)
Rubric for Review Paper (15 Marks) – PO4 (A)
| Criteria | Excellent (Full Marks) | Good | Satisfactory | Poor | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Understanding of Topic (3 marks) | Demonstrates deep, accurate, and relevant insight | Mostly accurate understanding | General understanding | Inaccurate or vague | /3 |
| Critical Analysis (4 marks) | Thoughtful synthesis with clear critique and comparison | Moderate level of analysis and interpretation | Some analysis but largely descriptive | Lacks critical engagement | /4 |
| Ethical and Professional Expression (3 marks) | Professional tone, well-referenced, no misconduct | Few minor errors in tone or citation | Some informal tone or citation issues | Poor tone, unclear citation or unethical use | /3 |
| Structure and Organisation (3 marks) | Clear, logical flow and well-linked sections | Generally organised and coherent | Structure present but weak transitions | Disorganised, lacks logical structure | /3 |
| Referencing and Formatting (2 marks) | APA used accurately throughout | Minor formatting inconsistencies | Multiple referencing issues | Unformatted or unclear referencing | /2 |
| Total | /15 | ||||
Please refer to the class slides on academic writing and review structure, and consult previous assignments as useful
input. You may discuss your draft with your supervisor or classmates, but your final submission must be your original work.
Get Help By Expert
Recent Solved Questions
- PCFE4013: This is an individual assignment that requires the students to do a summary writting on a selected articles: Foundations of Health and Epidemiology Assignment, ILKKM, Malaysia
- MIM711 Strategic Information Management Assignment Academic Writing Guidelines
- CDDS2103: Discuss the following topic(s) in the forum and submit proof of your participation in the online discussions: Introduction to Data Structure Course Work, OUM, Malaysia
- ENT300: Fundamentals of Entrepreneurship Report, UiTM, Malaysia On 1st November, my friend and I decided to start a business that focuses on gadget consulting services
- Pharmacology in Nursing Essay, MSU, Malaysia Discuss combined drug therapy for the management of cancer and the nursing implications when managing patients receiving this therapy
- FIT1043: Introduction to data science Assignment, MUM, Malaysia The Python programming language in the Jupyter Notebook environment It should also be formatted properly using the Markdown language
- FIN10004: Customers in the Corporate segment are often more likely to place larger orders than their consumer counterpart: Financial Statistic, Report, UTM, Malaysia
- Business Statistics Assignment, UU, Malaysia A researcher wishes to test the claim that the mean cost of tuition fees at a four-year private college for one semester is greater
- Statistics Assignment, USM, Malaysia Let X be an exponential random variable, Show that for a > 0 and b > 0
- G0302: Web Site Design Report, XUM, Malaysia Submitting or presenting someone else’s work, words, ideas, data or information as your own intentionally or unintentionally